If you're serious about pickleball, you've almost certainly landed on two names: Selkirk and JOOLA. Both are top-tier. Both are used by pros. Both make paddles that will genuinely improve your game. The real question isn't which brand is better — it's which one is better for you.
Pickle dug into both catalogs, tested the flagship models, and broke it all down so you can stop second-guessing and start playing. Here's everything you need to know.
Brand Overview
Selkirk Sport
Selkirk is as American as pickleball gets — headquartered in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho, and built from the ground up around the sport. Their VANGUARD line uses raw carbon fiber faces, which bite the ball aggressively for spin, while their polymer honeycomb cores are tuned for a quiet, controlled feel. Selkirk leans into the pro-tour ecosystem: they sponsor a large roster of PPA Tour players and engineer paddles that perform under tournament pressure. Expect to pay for it: VANGUARD paddles in our catalog list from $119.99.
Their SLK sub-brand brings the same DNA to a lower price point, making Selkirk accessible to players at every budget. If you want raw carbon fiber and don't have $200 to spare, SLK is your entry point.
JOOLA
JOOLA has a rich heritage in racket sports — the German brand has been making table tennis equipment since 1952. That engineering pedigree shows in their pickleball lineup. JOOLA's signature Swift C fiber (also marketed as Carbon Friction Surface, or CFS) is built to generate spin while maintaining a softer, more forgiving feel than raw carbon. Their partnership with Ben Johns — shapes the design of their flagship Hyperion line.
JOOLA covers a wide price spectrum: $89.95–$299.99 in our catalog. If you want pro-level tech without committing $200+ upfront, JOOLA probably has the right paddle for you.
Head-to-Head Comparison
| Category | Selkirk | JOOLA |
|---|---|---|
| Price range | $80–$333 (listed, our catalog) | $89.95–$299.99 (listed, our catalog) |
| Face material | Raw carbon fiber (T700) | Swift C fiber / Carbon Friction Surface |
| Core technology | Polymer honeycomb (Aero-Weave on some) | Reactive honeycomb (Charged polypropylene) |
| Feel | Firm, punchy, high spin potential | Softer, more forgiving, great spin with less effort |
| Power vs. Control | Slightly more power-biased | More balanced; control-friendly |
| Target player | Aggressive baseliners, bangers, spin lovers | All-rounders, kitchen players, soft-game focus |
| Pro endorsements | Large PPA roster | Ben Johns (a long-time world No. 1) |
Top Selkirk Paddles
Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air Invikta
Best for: Advanced players who want maximum spin and power
The VANGUARD Power Air Invikta is Selkirk's flagship. The raw carbon fiber face grabs the ball like velcro — you'll get spin numbers that will make your opponents miserable. The elongated shape gives you extra reach, and the airy core keeps the weight low without sacrificing pop. This paddle rewards aggressive play. If you like to attack from the baseline and rip passing shots, this is the one.
Check Price on Amazon →Selkirk SLK Halo Control XL
Best for: Intermediate to advanced players prioritizing control
Not in our catalog, so we don't list a price or specs for it here.
The SLK Halo Control XL brings genuine raw carbon quality at almost half the VANGUARD price. It's softer than the flagship — more forgiving, better at the kitchen line — while still generating impressive spin. This is Pickle's pick for players who want Selkirk DNA without the flagship price tag. Great for all-court play.
Check Price on Amazon →Selkirk SLK Evo Control XL
Best for: Beginners and budget-conscious players
Not in our catalog, so we don't list a price or specs for it here.
If you're just starting out or want to gift a solid paddle without spending $200, the SLK Evo Control XL hits the spot. Fiberglass face means a bit more pop and a larger sweet spot than carbon — forgiving for players still developing consistent mechanics. Selkirk's build quality shows even at this price. We'd also point you toward our best beginner paddles guide for more options at this level.
Check Price on Amazon →Top JOOLA Paddles
JOOLA Ben Johns Hyperion CAS 16
Best for: Advanced all-around players
Not in our catalog, so we don't list a price or specs for it here.
Ben Johns helped design this paddle, and it shows. The Hyperion CAS 16 is the rare paddle that excels at everything — power, control, touch, and spin. The Swift C fiber face is textured differently than raw carbon, producing a softer feel with just as much spin potential. The 16mm core gives it a satisfying, controlled pop. This is JOOLA's signature, and it's earned the reputation. Worth noting for tennis converts — check our best paddles for tennis players guide for more context on how feel translates from one sport to the other.
Check Price on Amazon →JOOLA Perseus CFS 16
Best for: Control-focused intermediate and advanced players
Not in our catalog, so we don't list a price or specs for it here.
The Perseus CFS 16 is JOOLA's elongated answer for players who want the extra reach of a longer paddle without sacrificing the soft, controlled feel the brand is known for. It's more forgiving than the Hyperion — a better fit for players who live at the kitchen line and rely on dink consistency rather than big drives. The CFS face still generates serious spin, just with a bit more touch dialed in.
Check Price on Amazon →JOOLA Scorpeus CFS 14
Best for: Power players and intermediate upgraders
Not in our catalog, so we don't list a price or specs for it here.
The 14mm core makes the Scorpeus CFS poppier and faster than its 16mm siblings — great if you're a natural power player who wants JOOLA quality without the Hyperion price. It's also a compelling upgrade from a beginner paddle. The tradeoff is a slightly smaller sweet spot and less blocking control, but power-focused players will love the extra zip. Also worth a look alongside the Wilson Blaze Pro 13 if you're evaluating power-oriented paddles in this range.
Check Price on Amazon →Who Should Buy Selkirk vs. JOOLA?
Choose Selkirk if you…
- ✅ Love aggressive, power-forward play
- ✅ Want maximum raw carbon spin bite
- ✅ Like a firm, punchy feel off the paddle face
- ✅ Follow the PPA Tour and prefer those player endorsements
- ✅ Are shopping on a budget (SLK paddles in our catalog list from $80)
- ✅ Prefer an American-made brand with strong domestic heritage
Choose JOOLA if you…
- ✅ Want a softer, more forgiving feel
- ✅ Love the kitchen game — dinking, drops, resets
- ✅ Want a Ben Johns signature paddle
- ✅ Prefer Swift C fiber's balanced spin-and-touch profile
- ✅ Need options across a wide price spectrum
- ✅ Are a tennis player drawn to the softer feel (similar to gut strings)
Pickle's honest take: if you're a banger or baseline attacker, Selkirk's raw carbon will reward you. If you're a strategist who wins with placement and touch, JOOLA's Swift C fiber is built for your game. Either way, you're buying a great paddle — the only bad choice here is spending $200 on a paddle that doesn't match your style.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Selkirk or JOOLA better for beginners?
JOOLA edges out Selkirk for beginners thanks to its wider price range and excellent entry-level options. That said, Selkirk's SLK Evo line is a genuine contender. For a deep dive on beginner-friendly picks across all brands, check our best beginner paddle guide.
Which brand do pros use?
Both have strong pro-tour presence. JOOLA is famously tied to Ben Johns. Selkirk sponsors a large roster of PPA Tour pros. You'll see both brands at the highest levels of competition.
How do Selkirk and JOOLA compare on price?
In our catalog, JOOLA paddles list at $89.95–$299.99 and Selkirk paddles at $80–$333. Selkirk's SLK line covers the budget end ($80–$200), and VANGUARD paddles list at $119.99–$249.99.
What is the best Selkirk paddle?
The Selkirk VANGUARD Power Air Invikta is the flagship — raw carbon fiber, airy core, and massive sweet spot. For a more accessible option, the SLK Halo Control XL is a lower-priced option.
What is the best JOOLA paddle?
The JOOLA Ben Johns Hyperion CAS 16 is a well-known JOOLA paddle, co-designed with Ben Johns, that balances power and control. If you want more spin focus, the Perseus CFS 16 is worth a serious look.
Still not sure which paddle is right for you?
Pickle's paddle selector asks a few quick questions and recommends the right paddle for your game — free, no signup.
Try the Paddle SelectorExplore More Guides
Pickle has reviewed paddles across every category — beginner setups, power weapons, women's picks, and more.
Browse All Guides →In our catalog
Paddle pages for the models this guide discusses
Selkirk paddle pages in our catalog
Alphabetical.
JOOLA paddle pages in our catalog
Alphabetical.